| Printable Version of Topic
Click here to view this topic in its original format |
| Celtic Radio Community > Scotland > The Royal Scots & Black Watch Are No More |
| Posted by: Macfive 28-Mar-2006, 09:11 PM |
| From Scotmans.com "IN BASRA, the sun beat down on the soldiers gathered in the dust of Shaibah camp. In Edinburgh, a light drizzle fell on the men and women lined up on parade at the top of the castle. In Glasgow, Baghdad, Omagh, Belfast, Cyprus and Canterbury, similar ceremonies were taking place. As midday struck in Scotland, the country's old regiments slipped into history. Gone were the Royal Scots - almost 400 years old - the Black Watch, the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders, the Royal Highland Fusiliers, the King's Own Scottish Borderers and the Highlanders. In their place, to a flurry of pipes and drums, was the new Royal Regiment of Scotland" http://news.scotsman.com/politics.cfm?id=483052006 |
| Posted by: teashoci 29-Mar-2006, 03:37 AM |
| ........... good riddance to them |
| Posted by: John Clements 29-Mar-2006, 09:21 AM |
| I think that some things should be changed, no matter what, and I’m only glad that my Dad isn’t alive to have heard this news. And I say good riddance’s to you, for I would have been proud, to have stood in the ranks, of the Black Watch. |
| Posted by: teashoci 29-Mar-2006, 11:29 AM |
| are you scottish john clements ?, and why would you want to fight for the black watch |
| Posted by: teashoci 29-Mar-2006, 11:33 AM |
| it says on your profile that you are in america, so assuming that you are american and not scottish why would you fight for the black watch ?, have a horrendous two faced history, from slaughtering and oppresing highland jacobites to the atrocities they comitted in ireland throught the 20th century. but you wouldnt know the kinship or culture of the black watch being american would you |
| Posted by: Shadows 29-Mar-2006, 05:30 PM |
| A very SAD day! |
| Posted by: Shadows 29-Mar-2006, 05:42 PM | ||
Being an American I can tell you these regiments had a very large hand in shaping our history on this side of the pond! We the colonists ( now citizens ) of this now great country, fought hard and long both with and against these soldiers of the crown and over came them to become our own nation... To not morn the bravery, fortitude, and commitment of these regiments would be a slap in the face to all that served in the "French and Indian" as well as the Revoluntionary Wars here on the left side of the pond. These were great soldiers and to see them diminished into obscurity makes me sad. |
| Posted by: MacEoghainn 29-Mar-2006, 05:51 PM | ||
Shadows and I don't always agree (some might say we never agree on anything, probably because we're both descended from stubborn Scots!  ) but on this point I'm in 100% agreement with him!  |
| Posted by: Shadows 29-Mar-2006, 06:15 PM | ||
 What makes it worse MacE is we both er of the same clan...  Long live the stubborn Scots of all clans! |
| Posted by: John Clements 29-Mar-2006, 07:01 PM |
| Teashoci, yes I may have been born in America, but both my Mother and Farther were born in Scotland, and the way I see it, that makes me as Scots as I want to be. As to the history of the Black Watch, although I may not know as much as you, what I do know is, that in recent history, the Black Watch are about as distinguished a regiment, as you can get. Maybe you can direct me to some reading material that could change my opinion, and maybe you can tell my why, the hair on the back of my neck stands up, when I hear a piper blowing amazing Grace? |
| Posted by: teashoci 30-Mar-2006, 10:50 AM |
| The black watch are a horrible institute that panders to the ideology of the oppressive english crown,none of these so called scots fight for themselvs they only fight for their english masters,in particuler serving in n.ireland to crush and kill irish republicans and civilians. I myself am a scottish republican who belives in an irish , scottish and welsh republic. I do not consider myself anti english,I do however despise the british crown like many other scots ,welsh ,irish and even some english. That is why i would never dream of throwing away or re writing my history to join the black watch and fight for an english queen and country. The black watch does not represent scottish culture it represents oppression. I am not writing this statement to offend anyone,But i have a write to divulge my views on the black watch when yu are talking about them. With respect to you john clementine,for you to dismiss my argument just because you like amazing grace played on the bagpipes shows nothing but ignorance. And your typical american sentimentality makes me cringe. |
| Posted by: teashoci 30-Mar-2006, 10:58 AM |
| I also apologize if you think i was disputing your scots heritage i was not,nor did i mean to put it across in that manner. for information on black watch and oppressive english rule i would suggest books on: black watch history union of the crowns easter rising in ireland (where the black watch played a cowardly part in) ireland and n.ireland -a tragic shame The jacobite rebellion ( where the black watch fought for the english ad slaughtered their own countrymen) The ist could go on |
| Posted by: fiferbob 19-Mar-2007, 05:08 AM |
| teasochi i am glad you have the mind to have formed the opinions you have but have you ever thought where the freedom to think and develop those ideas came from? Dare i mention the bravery of the scots regiments in two world wars but please remember without those brave lads you would have been in a state where freedom of speech and thought was quickly disposed of. Pretty much the way blair and his cronies would like us to go. So please continue to use ur mind but in developing your thoughts and ideas take a view of the wider picture |
| Posted by: Sekhmet 19-Mar-2007, 01:10 PM |
| Hi there...Teaoshci has moved on to other pastures, so he's going to be unable to answer your question. Just letting you and other readers of this thread know so you don't get upset or confused because he doesn't answer. |
| Posted by: Dogshirt 19-Mar-2007, 07:36 PM |
Can't say as I will miss his belligerent attitude!  |
| Posted by: Golden_Griffin 16-Apr-2007, 11:16 PM |
| I was devestated to hear of the disolving of all these regiments but I also rember hearing the stories about the black watch from my Irish great grandmother. Although they are gone now and may the change be better for the Great Scottish Lands. |
