The Philosophy, Science & Religion forum has been created as an unmoderated forum. The issues discussed here can and will get very intense. Please show respect and appreciation to alternative views posted here. We appreciate your consideration.
Music is holy, art is sacred, and creativity is power
Everyday is EARTH DAY to a farmer
"Always forgive your enemies; nothing annoys them so much." Oscar Wilde
Some men are drawn to oceans, they cannot breathe unless the air is scented with a salty mist. Others are drawn to land that is flat, and the air is sullen and is leaden as August. My people were drawn to mountains- Earl Hamner Jr.
I never heard of such a thing. All the archaeological evidence I've ever heard of supported the idea that humanity originated in the savannas of Africa and spread from there. If you believe in the theory of evolution (and I do), man could not have arisen from apes it he had come from the arctic.
--------------------
Cheers! Todd
Normal is a relative term. For some reason it is not a term my relatives use to describe me.
Realm: second star to the right, straight until morning
QUOTE (tsargent62 @ 09-Jun-2004, 03:29 PM)
I never heard of such a thing. All the archaeological evidence I've ever heard of supported the idea that humanity originated in the savannas of Africa and spread from there. If you believe in the theory of evolution (and I do), man could not have arisen from apes it he had come from the arctic.
Oh, I agree!!! I just threw it out there...... There is far to much evidence out of Africa that supports that theory.
In school we learned about the Out of Africa Theory (which I believe) and........can't remember the other one, but it wasn't that.
--------------------
DRAGON BLESSING
May dragons bring you wealth and guard your treasures May they banish darkness and enlighten you May female dragons grant you inner power May the Dragon Queen neutralize your enemies May Dragon Spirits give you power over Elementals May weather dragons bring rain at your request May Ti'amat effect the changes you command May Ishtar grant you Dragon Power May Ishtar grant you Dragon Power
Group: Celtic Nation
Posts: 911
Joined: 18-Nov-2003 Zodiac: Oak
As always, one must consider the source: Pravda (which is Russian for truth) is not known for being terribly concerned with veracity. Interestingly, a book I have been reading, "The Real Eve," presents credible evidence to support the theory that the initial migrations out of Africa were to Asia and points east, and that there were at least two migrations from Asia to Europe--a earlier souther one and a later northern one. I can't help wondering whether the Pravda story may be a misinterpretation of archeological finds relating the later migration from Asia to Europe. Yet another example of interesting stuff I'll never have the time to follow up on.
This theory has a lot of hallmarks of self-fulfilling prophecy. Russian scientists, in a northern climate, formulate a theory that mankind originated in the north and migrated south. Then, they find a little evidence that they can make fit the theory and ignore the preponderance of conflicting theory. It is similar to the approach of "creation science".
Scientific data has all sorts of variance. Good science weeds out the bogus data and weighs the preponderance of the evidence.
--------------------
Näkemiin
Dave (SCA: Geoffrey Genour of Carney) Protector of Bits and Bytes, Third cousin once removed to Phil, Prince of Insufficient Light
Help out with the site! Win prizes! Suggest videos at VideoCelt.com
An interesting idea, but I would have to agree with dfilpus in so far as it smells rather self-satisfying. It sort of reminds me of how Chekhov in the original Star Trek used to claim that a Russian was always behind all the greatest discoveries and inventions. I might be more inclined to believe then if they had more substantial evidence to support their claims...
Group: Founder
Posts: 304
Joined: 02-Aug-2004 Zodiac: Oak
Realm: Orlando, FL
I was watching Scientific American (or whatever Alan Alda's PBS show is called), and there is yet another theory that says that while early man DID come from Russia (and cross the Bering Straits and migrate down in to southern North America), there is a belief that they made it further east than originally thought.
And while I don't doubt that there is some validity to the Out of Africa theory, I am given to wonder if both theories have some merit.
Either there is a point of origin that predates both of them, or maybe there were two (or three) points of origin at almost the same time.
Just my too sense.
--------------------
[color=blue][b]Erik Deckers Visit my weekly humor blog Laughing Stalk[COLOR=blue]
[QUOTE]ignore the preponderance of conflicting theory
Wait a minute if it is only THEORY with some proof could it not be wrong? Just because somebody else came up with a theory that has some merit does not mean that it is completely right. That is what science is, people formulate theories all the time then TEST and OBSERVE those theories. Early human migration cannot be tested and observed, unfortunatly ( as in we can't turn on a tv or go into the field and watch Ancestor 1 move from Moscow to London), so one persons theories are just as valid as others. (now there may not be much evidence to support that theory, but is there any solid evidence-beyond any doubt-to say that the theory is wrong) Have archeologists found everything there is to find? What if there was a civilization that predates the earliest ones we can find, but they burned the bodies of their dead and lived in grass huts (which would erode and be destroyed over time)? They would leave little to no evidence of their existence and scientists would be working with incomplete data. What if the dates that are givin for these people groups are wrong? Wouldn't we have to readjust our migration patterns? Remember Evolution is only a theory also so we can't use one theory to say another theory is wrong. We can say these thoeries either support each other or don't, but one theory does not disprove another no matter how much you believe a theory to be fact.
Now Mailagnas had a point, consider the source though. Pravda was not known for being entirly truthful.
--------------------
Friendship, Love, and Loyalty
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)